Something that complicates it is the overall square footage–people do count the garage as usable square footage–because it is storage space, or could be a living room. So it would be valid to say "What would a 3BR, 2BA, 1400 sq ft house with 2 car garage have gone for… But I still think $550K in 2012 was a steal in that area for that. Should still have been $750K and up.
But houses on the Alameda itself were selling for more…
Doubtful. You can sell houses in Selby Lane district for $2M nowadays. 1/3 of RWC kids do private schools. And the nearby houses were going for more.