More Americans are sleeping in cars than ever before. Should cities make space for them?

Each night at 6 p.m., San Diego’s New Life Assembly church opens its parking lot to dozens of people who will spend the night in their cars. The church is one of three sites in the city where the homeless can park overnight without fear of being ticketed or towed—or worse. It’s part of a citywide safe parking program started in 2010 to confront an increasingly visible face of the state’s homelessness epidemic: Californians sleeping in their cars.

As housing costs soar in major cities, more Americans are living behind the wheel. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development doesn’t collect national data on vehicle residency, but unsheltered homelessness—a category that includes people sleeping in vehicles—is on the rise. In 2016, HUD counted 176,357 unsheltered people nationwide on a single night; last year, that number jumped to 192,875. In King County, Washington (which includes Seattle), about 3,372 people—more than half of the county’s unsheltered population—are living in vehicles. And in Greater Los Angeles, which has the largest unsheltered homeless population in the country, more than 15,000 people live in cars, vans, and RVs.

It is definitely out of the box thinking, but not sure that is the best solution. It would be better if these folks were housed cheaply somehow so that they can get rid of the car expense so that they can get perhaps get back on the road to solvency. Yes, it will be hard.

Don’t we all see homeless people with dogs or they carry cell phones. Uh, you can’t even feed/house yourself so why did you have a dog? Honestly, why do you need a cell phone? That is just more money out of your welfare checks that could go to better use. And let’s not mention the drugs, alcohol and cigarette use…

Whatever happened to all the FEMA trailers?
Apparently they were sold at fire sale prices and none are left.
They cost $40k new

https://www.usnews.com/news/us/articles/2017-09-15/fema-auctioned-disaster-trailers-as-harvey-made-landfall

2 Likes

San Diego actually has a law on the books prohibiting people from sleeping in cars an RVs. Two days ago a judge issued an injunction to prevent the them from enforcing it.

1 Like

Pretty much all judges I am finding are useless. They simply are not enforcing the laws on the books. Whether it is punishing 3 strikers or stuff like this. What is the point of these laws if you aren’t going to enforce them?

3 Likes

Actually, I was wondering why they don’t park their RV in a Wal-Mart parking lot overnight, where they are welcome to stay, instead of on the street.

That’s because any law that doesn’t have equal outcomes for all people is racist. People assume the percent of people arrested and guilty of crimes should exactly follow country demographics. They completely ignore differences in behavior, and blame everything on differences in enforcement. It’s quite alarming.

Vice: The Hidden Homelessness Crisis In California

There is a shortage of affordable housing in every state in the country, but it’s especially bad in California — where there’s only one affordable housing unit for every five extremely low income households.

The gap is not only pushing more and more people out onto the streets—it’s also creating a new, fast-growing, and hidden class of homelessness: People who in the past would have been able to afford a room or apartment but now live in their cars by necessity.

Danielle Williams is one of them. She’s a single working mother who has been living in her van with her daughter for five years. At first, it meant sleeping in dark, scarcely populated areas, and being hassled by the police. But thanks to a program called Safe Parking — a network of parking lots equipped with porta-potties and lot monitors — she can now stay in her car overnight without worrying about her safety.

VICE News traveled to California to see how the new program is helping people like Danielle live a little more comfortably, and met with a government official who’s frustrated there aren’t longer term solutions to help the roughly 16,000 people in Los Angeles who now sleep in their cars.

Her expenses for herself and teenage daughter:

Why is the focus always on affordable housing? Why doesn’t anyone want to talk about how we can help people increase their income?

There are non-profits for probably people of younger age that aims to solve their housing problem first and then give them training and prep for SWE jobs.

More housing needs to built. Cities could easily up zone, remove restrictions and fees. Allowing cars as housing is pathetic.

1 Like

The results of 50 years of environmentalists protesting housing developments… the solutions are draconian at best. Blame the landlords the developers. But never look inward and blame environmentalists, liberals, rent control and nymbies… an am sick to death of them…

Maybe I am naive, but I always think providing safe parking for vehicle dwellers shouldn’t cost a lot of money. City and county usually have excess land that are just sitting there. Enclose with fence and provide some basic bathroom/shower service and garbage service in my view should be fairly low cost. Basically run it like a campground. Providing a better quality of life for people living in their vehicles should be a great way of preventing homelessness. So why don’t people do it?

If my understanding is correct, then we should be able to extend it to homeless folks living in tents rather than vehicles. Just providing that kind of shelter and basic needs shouldn’t cost much. I would guess that the expensive part is to provide other services like mental health/physical health/drug-rehab/job-search/real-housing/case-manager-counseling/etc.

Trailer parks are the solution. Tried and true American concept… problem is nobody wants trailer parks in their neighborhoods…
Management is the key. You have to be a tough son of a bitch to manage trailer parks and most low income housing. Too many low lifes, crime, drugs, fights, evictions… no easy solutions

3 Likes

Well, you’ve hit the nail on the head there. Managing trailer parks and low-income housing can be a real challenge, but you’re right, it’s not an easy problem to solve.