More Oakland Press

Winds sure change fast.

Is this the same lady who created a fight between Oakland PD and immigration ?

It’s actually comforting to know that in the face of high crime rates these progressives will change course rather than sticking it out.

Why did they try it in the first place though? I think even elementary school kids could predict the outcome.

I’m all for law and order in the streets and in the board rooms but I believe there is more to our issues of crime than pure spending levels.

.

Progressives have IQ similar to chimpanzee? Just kidding.

1 Like

For liberals and progressive, fighting crime means begging criminals to do no crime in exchange of money. Net result is that criminals take money and crime graph keeps rising.

Isn’t TX opposite of liberals and progressives? Why are property and violent crime almost same as CA?

1 Like

I do not think property and crime in TX is same as CA. But, even if you say it is true, should TX also give money to criminals to not do crime?

Sounds same as saying an unemployed to no take a job in exchange of some money called unemployment benefit.

.

,

Wait what??? I thought they wanted to Defund the Police.

How quickly people learn…

This article refers to SF data and retail theft, however Oakland data should be similar. Even San Jose more or less similar trending data, although on an absolute scale better than SF and Oakland. My guess is this less reporting of crime data is across different categories of crime in SF Bay Area, although homicide should be proportionally better than the rest.

My own experience with breakage of my car is similar where 3/4 people whose cars were broken into didn’t file a report with the police.

But crime experts say the data required to accurately measure shoplifting is woefully inadequate.
A closer look at the data shows that the spike in reported shoplifting came almost entirely from one store: the Target at 789 Mission St. in the Metreon mall. In September alone, 154 shoplifting reports were filed from the South of Market intersection where the Target stands, up from 13 in August. And then, in October, the reports from this intersection went down again to 17.

What happened at this particular Target? Did the store see a huge spike in shoplifting in September? No, said store manager Stacy Abbott. The store was simply using a new reporting system implemented by the police that allows retailers to report crime incidents over the phone.

Though the spike seen in the data generates more questions than answers, one thing is clear: A single (albeit large and busy) store’s decision to report a majority of its shoplifting incidents doubled the entire city’s monthly shoplifting rates.

The lack of clear data means that the debate over issues like shoplifting is not grounded in clear facts, allowing each side in the divide to say it is right.

They argue that police data will always be inaccurate because in a city that has historically struggled with high property-crime rates, store workers either don’t witness or don’t report most incidents. And they say leniency in the criminal justice system plays a role, with stores forgoing reports because they figure people won’t be punished anyway.

https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/shoplifting-data-Target-Walgreens-16647769.php

1 Like

yes only 1/3 of property crimes are reported all over USA and it’s not unique to just BA.

That seems to be an average of all states. So all the highs and lows got mashed into a single number without giving an insight into which state or metropolitan area contributes to what. So, yeah no idea which area is unique or not unique.

Look at the CA property crime rates after 2015 in the graph below. And these numbers are only till 2018. Things have gotten much worse in CA since then.

One single store, when Target faithfully used the new system and mysteriously(didn’t use it again, my guess) the number varied sharply as below:

(154-13)/13 * 100= 1084% increase in September from August
(154-17)/17 * 100= 89% decrease in October from September

I don’t have detailed data either, however even if I reduce the Target number by half, these numbers are overwhelmingly bad and more closely matches with the narrative.

1 Like
1 Like

Property crime rates are 0 in California because nothing gets counted as theft. It is like saying stealing is legal in California.

2 Likes